Archive

Posts Tagged ‘magiq-to-entities’

Magiq to Entities – An update

May 7, 2011 2 comments

The past days I’ve been working on making Magiq work with Entity Framework.

First I tried to work with the MetadataWorkspace and I gave up, ’cause its really impossible to get the mapping information. Luckily, I found Linq to Edmx project who does exactly what I needed.

Then I had some troubles working with the Queryables generated by the ObjectSets. Basically, the expression generated calls methods that doesn’t work and are there only to give information in the expression. So the expression is not something you can compile and execute. As big part of Magiq is to manipulate expression trees, that was a really big problem. I needed to figure out how to change the source queryable (I mean, the queryable where all the methods are applied to) to a simple ObjectSet. Besides it works now, I’m still working to get to a nicer way (you don’t want to know what I have done to make it work…).

Since I changed the insert API from having the new item expression (the new{…}) outside to have it as a select, I had to break the query in two, the select and the “rest”. Ok, that gave me more headaches :).

But the biggest problem was when Entity Framework started to change the order of the columns in the select (and add new columns). Let me explain how Linq to Sql works:

If you do this:

items.Where( ... ).Select( x => new { A = x.Prop1, B = x.Prop2, C = x.Prop2 /*again*/ });

Linq to sql transate it to:

SELECT prop1, prop2, prop2 FROM items WHERE ...

But Entity Framework removes the repeated columns and maybe reorders them, giving you something like:

SELECT prop2, prop1 FROM items WHERE ...

You don’t have any idea of the reflection tricks I had to make to get those property-select columns mapping.

But well, those are not bad news at all. I mean I could work around them and I can say Magiq now supports Entity Framework (with a few restrictions). Those are:

  • Only Table per class hierarchy inheritance is supported. I’m currently working on the Table per concrete class and Table per type strategies
  • Only mapped associations are supported. This means associations based on foreign keys are not (yet).
  • Only mapped POCOs are supported. This means Self Tracking entities and Code First are not (yet).

Keep in touch for the updates 🙂

Advertisements